Entrance/Exit slip: September 10
I’ll start by saying that the overall idea behind the whole interview is a positive one, and one interesting approach that McCourt adopted was weaving between the two competing schools of thought of “don’t tell too much about yourself when teaching” and “be open with the kids”. The idea of dropping the act is not about sharing absolutely everything about your personal life, it is just not having a persona. It's about not wearing a mask, even if you have to set some boundaries. The constant effort of not being yourself every day must be draining, and there is a chance your personality will slip and show up, and that’s why McCourt mentions that you will most likely eventually drop the act.
Even if I agree and understand most of what was said, there were two things that I noticed that could have been put in a more sensible way.
The first was when McCourt mentioned his difficult past and his successful escape from those difficulties. I understand his early life may have been hard, and I am glad he was able to overcome it and rise to a better life. What I think could have been better would be the recognition of the things that played a role in his survival of his miserable childhood. The way he attributes his success to his dreaming about getting out of it could imply that the ones that don’t succeed just didn’t dream hard enough. Dreaming of escaping a difficult situation may be crucial to not giving up, but just not giving up is not enough to succeed. Many things can influence the overcoming of a situation, and more often than not, luck is part of it. Attributing the whole success to a thing as simple as just dreaming, something that anyone could do, can come across as a bit shallow and disregard important factors that are not accessible to everyone.
The other moment was when he mentioned how the GI Bill helped him get admission and embark on the teaching career. Even though the GI Bill was a benefit for him, the circumstances that made the bill possible and the global context around the situation that brought him this opportunity are less lucky than he made it seem. He mentions that "luckily enough" there was a war, he was drafted into the U.S. Army, and he could benefit from the GI Bill. I understand that being somewhat favourable for him, but I would not say any kind of human conflict where lives are lost is a lucky situation.
I get that the main goal of the video was not about those two slips, but sometimes the intended message is not exactly what draws most of the attention.
No comments:
Post a Comment