Monday, October 26, 2026

Ropes and Poems

Exit Slip: October 8

Ropes

This exercise was really interesting. One problem that I had with the activity was that at the end we were expected to show our ropes. And I had none. What I was doing was trying different fibre type compositions (grass and/or corn husk) and the number of strands. I was twisting the strands to make a rope, and when I had a long enough rope, I would pull it until it snapped. I was just testing the maximum load of the rope. And then I would try with one more strand, or with the other type of fibre, or mix the fibres, and test the maximum load again. So at the end I had no rope to show. I had just many snapped and destroyed segments of rope. Which is not exactly great. But I had a lot of data points.

I think a lot of the process can be connected to math. For example, in a way, the sequential nature of rope twisting is pretty similar to the sequential nature of mathematical algorithms. Where one step done wrong can compromise the entire resulting rope/solution.

But more than that, I think there is a real physical and mathematical experiment that can be done with the strands and the rope. Twisting the rope reduces the length of the strand while increasing the thickness, and, as expected, increasing the maximum load of the rope. And then we could start using math and experiments to make calculations:

  • Measuring the maximum load of isolated strands and many strands, does the maximum load increase linearly?
  • Do both fibres have the same maximum load per amount of fibre? Or are they different?
  • Assuming the volume of the rope stays the same, how could we calculate the increase in thickness given a measured decrease in length of the strands?
  • How much of the rope’s maximum load depends on the thickness (or the area of the cross-section) of the rope?

This all feels more “Physics Lab” than “Math Class”, but I think they are not too far apart. This may be my Mechanical Engineering background surfacing in my teaching ideas. Still doable, I think, and still instructional.

Poems

The poem activity was a bit harder for me. I don’t consider myself a highly on-demand-creative person, so writing a poem in a few minutes is harder for me. I appreciate doing that as a group exercise, because I honestly didn’t do much. But I was, in my head, constantly thinking about something individual. And I didn’t get to a nice poem. But I got to some ideas that I later iterated on.

Keeping in mind the 27 digits: 2.71828182845904523536028747.

My original idea was to have a nice word-by-word poem, where each digit would be a word, and I thought about having the text be minimally mathematical, and maybe, if possible, having the “words” be mathematical symbols.

The ending 8747 I immediately thought of having it as “for ever and ever”, that would already lock 8 = “for”, 7 = “ever”, and 4 = “and”. And I thought that, for representing that as mathematical symbols we could have “for” as being a “4”, “ever” could be “∞” maybe, and “and” could be the logical “∧”. It wasn’t good, honestly, but the idea was not absolutely discarded.

Just with the 8 fixed as “for”, that would make the 18281828 to be “1 for 2 for 1 for 2 for”. That segment is also limited by a 7 on the left and a 4 on the right, making the segment be “ever 1 for 2 for 1 for 2 for and”.

The “for and” was not great, but I thought that maybe “for and” could be “for and by” something. That would lock 5 as by, and the 9 would be something, and that’s good, because the 9 there is the only occurrence of 9, so we are completely free of what to put in there.

So far we have “2 ever 1 for 2 for 1 for 2 for and by 9 0 and by 2 3 by 3 6 0 2 for ever and ever”.

The “for 1 for 2” I thought could be “for you for me”, and I iterated that, it wasn’t terrible, but that would make the start 271 to be “me ever you”, or “you ever me”, depending on which one of 1 and 2 would be “me” and which one would be “you”. It was bad. And that’s where my in-class thought process ended. I wasn’t happy about that. But I had to do something, and so I joined a group and focused on the group work. And we did okay. It was a good experience working with the group, and they were really creative. I was not able to finish a poem entirely by myself with the given time. A couple students did solo poems and group poems, but I'm not that fast with on-demand creativity.

But I didn’t stop thinking about it, and I iterated on it, and I tried to make it work. I ended up giving up the idea of mathematical symbols and also gave up on the idea of making the poem mathematical. I could not justify trying to make it mathematical, and the symbols for “ever”, “for”, and “and” were not great, but adding the “by” made it even worse. So it was just a poem now.

I still had “me” and “you” as base ideas for 1 and 2, but it wasn’t great, but we can try using “someone” and “another” as placeholders: “someone ever another, for someone, for another, for someone, for and by 9 0 and by someone 3 by 3 6 0 someone for ever and ever”.

With the idea of “me” and “you” or “someone” and “another”, the “for and by 9”, we could have 9 as “us” or “everyone”. That wouldn’t be terrible. Then we have the “6 0” close before the “for ever and ever”, and before that the “3 by 3”. Looking at the “3 by 3”, I could only think of “4 by 4”, but that’s not it! I could think of “little by little”.

The poem was starting to get form, but my efforts were starting to reach my literary limit. I spent most of my efforts thinking about the 1 and 2, which I was not happy about. Then I had the idea of making it educational, using “teachers” and “students”. That could work! We would have:

Teachers, ever students,
For teachers, for students, for teachers,
For and by us 0
And by teachers, little by little
6 0
Teachers, for ever and ever.

That was my limit. I then resorted to brainstorming with AI, and it gave me good directions. For the 6, Claude suggested “until”, and for the 0 “now”. So we would have:

…
For and by us now
…
Until now
…

That was a start, but not great. I then changed the line of “until now” to “from now”, but it was still not good, though I thought it had a good synergy with “for ever and ever”. But it would be best if it was “from now on”, but then “for and by us now on” was not good. Then I thought about “today” instead of “now”, so we would have

…
For and by us today
…
From today
Teachers, for ever and ever.

Not bad at all! But the “for and by us” was not great. Maybe “for and by everyone”. Or maybe, as Claude suggested, “for and by the people”, but then having 9 as "the people", it would be the only digit to have two words in it, so I stuck with "everyone". Claude also suggested "step by step" for the 353, and I liked it.

I don’t know, I’m not great with poems in my first language. And in English it’s even worse. But my final composition was:

Given the base 2.71828182845904523536028747

And ordering it as

271
828182
84590
452353
60
28747

And having:

  1. today
  2. students
  3. teachers
  4. step
  5. and
  6. by
  7. from
  8. ever
  9. for
  10. everyone

With that, the final product was:

Teachers, ever students,
For teachers, for students, for teachers,
For and by everyone today,
And by teachers, step by step,
From today,
Teachers, for ever and ever.

And that was good enough for me. Could possibly be improved, but not by me.

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Animacy, Moral Responsibility, Intent

Entrance Slip: October 8

This was a very conflicting reading for me.

I'll start by recognizing and acknowledging Dr. Kimmerer's journey with reconnecting with her native ancestral language.

I agree with Dr. Kimmerer that there is a common view that the natural living world is just "natural resources", but what was conflicting for me was the crusade against the language. I think this is a fight against indifference towards nature, not a fight against the dictionary. I know this chapter of the "Braiding Sweetgrass" book is called "Learning the Grammar of Animacy", so it would be fitting that language is mentioned, but I think there is some kind of reverse causality in the way it was approached.

The Moral Responsibility

I agree that most humans are strongly disconnected from nature, but I don't think that's just because of the language. I believe the language was created in a way that reflected the culture and behaviour of their creators. I also understand that language can tweak our perception of our surroundings, but I honestly don't believe that lack of animacy grammar in a language is what absolves us of moral responsibility and allows for exploitation. I think that, if there is any connection between the two, it was our lack of moral responsibility that led us to not have animacy in our grammar.

Another argument to debunk that language forces moral responsibility is that humans refer to humans as humans. And it is absolutely evident that not all humans treat humans as humans. And I'm saying that in 2026! You start moving backwards in time, and things get way worse. We've seen war, we've seen slavery, we've seen domestic violence, we've seen humans exploiting humans, and we've seen much more. Using "who" instead of "it" never prevented anyone from atrocities. So no, that's not it. And we've also seen the atrocities (or intent of atrocity) change the way some humans were addressed. But that change in the language was caused by the change of the mentality.

Dr. Kimmerer comments that "if a maple is an it, we can take up the chain saw" and that "if a maple is a her, we think twice." Well, maples were not native to Brazil, but in Portuguese all trees (as everything else) are either she or he, and that didn't stop the chain saw... I know that in Portuguese the trees are not "who", they are "what", which can make a difference, but the "she" instead of "it" didn't help.

Another problem comes with lack of intent. When things get too automatic, they start losing their meaning. So even if we called the trees "someone", not "something", we would have to mean it. And language itself doesn't force that intentional feeling. For example, people can say "thank you" to someone who holds the door for them, but they can do that just out of reflex, or because that's what's socially expected, without even meaning it.

So when Andy asks "wouldn’t things be different if nothing was an it?" Then I'd have to say, "I'm sorry, Andy, but it's not that simple. Most likely things wouldn't be different." I could try to argue with Andy that maybe nothing would be an it because things were different, and not that things would be different because nothing was an it. That idea is even expressed by the field biologist who shifted her language to accommodate her relationships.

The Language

The first major problem I had with the reading regarding language was when Dr. Kimmerer said that English is a tongue viewed as the most useful, with the richest vocabulary in the modern world, and that it is used by 70% of the world's people. I really don't know about that statistic of English speakers, and I don't think I agree that English is the most useful with the richest vocabulary. It is great for communicating with people who can speak it. It is the most used language in the world, but it got to that status because of geopolitics, historical power, and modern economics, not because of inherent linguistic usefulness or richness.

Moving Forward

What I think is needed is a shift in the mindset. A change in culture. Even if the language doesn't change, if we make part of our culture a behaviour of non-exploitation, then that's enough. For example, it is engrained into the minds of U.S. citizens an unconditional love and respect for the flag. And the flag is unmistakably an "it". Why not extend that love and respect to other "it"s?

Monday, October 19, 2026

Apple Cider

Exit Slip: October 1

I’ll start by admitting that making apple cider was definitely not on my UBC Bachelor of Education bingo card…

It was really good, though!

Even with the spider!

The Process

There were many tasks: setting up the working tables, assembling the press, putting up the canopies to protect from the rain, washing parts, and, no less important, understanding how the water valve works. Many students played different roles in the process, but we had only one that really understood the water valve, so whenever we needed water, we had to call the one known as The Water Bender.

I did mostly washing at the beginning and then pulling the manual food processor string. Handling the manual food processor was a dangerous task, as the blades are insanely sharp and you have to constantly open it and remove the blades to remove the minced apple. It was arduous and dangerous, but we managed to end the day with but a single small injury. I call it a success!

One interesting thing was the oxidation of the apple. When I think of apple juice, I don't think of a brown juice. I understand the oxidation process, but it's a different scale. Everything was brown! 

After a whole pitcher of apple juice, some students brought berries to add to the press to make an apple-berry juice! It was nice to mix things up a bit, and after pressing the juice, we found a spider inside the press. No one is completely sure how it didn't squish the spider, but it was alive afterwards, so we didn't drink spider juice. Worst case, if it was scared, we may have had some spider sweat! (I'm pretty sure they don't do that, though.)

The Math

I think the most basic math for this activity would be just the proportion of apples to juice.

There is also the basic idea of a function. The press is a juice maker: you input apple, it outputs apple juice; you input berry, it makes berry juice. Basically, juice of \(x\)!

Then there is a deeper math to be explored with the browning of the apple. The browning is oxidation that happens on the surface of the apple, while the insides of the apple remain fresh. That is the idea I want to explore a bit more.

The Browning of the Apple

There are two simple approaches that I thought of that show that the more you cut the apple, the browner everything gets:

  • If we think that if we cut the apple in half, each half of the apple will have exactly half of the volume of the original apple, and each half will have exactly half of the surface of the apple plus the amount of new surface you created with the cut. Basically, with every cut you are never adding more apple flesh but are always adding more exposed surface.
  • A bit more complex, but still simple to understand, is the idea that the volume is a cubic measurement and that the surface is a square measurement. Whatever the shape, a cube or a sphere, the surface divided by the volume is proportional to \(\frac{L^2}{L^3} = \frac{1}{L}\), so it is inversely proportional to the size of the piece. Halving the size doubles the exposed surface per unit of apple.

Sadly for this example, I may have to borrow from the classic physics metaphorical joke of a perfectly spherical and homogenous apple in the vacuum with no friction. Okay, possibly not in the vacuum, because it needs to be exposed to oxygen to oxidize... And maybe a cubic apple would be easier to calculate, honestly.

But imagining that the apple is a cube, that the browning of the apple happens only on the flesh of the apple, not on the juice after it is pressed, and that the browning happens for only a specific depth, then we can model the browning of the apple!

If we assume a peeled cubic apple of side \(L\), with browning depth of \(d\), the volume of the apple is \(L^3\), the exposed surface of the apple is \(6L^2\), and the volume of browned apple would be \(L^3 - (L - 2d)^3\)[1]. If we cut the length \(L\) in half we would have \(8\) pieces of volume \(\left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^3\), and the total volume of browned apple would be \(8\left[\left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{2} - 2d\right)^3\right]\). If we cut the length \(L\) in \(n\) segments we would have \(n^3\) pieces of volume \(\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3\), and the total volume of browned apple would be \(n^3\left[\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3\right]\). We can see by that formula for the browned apple that when \(\frac{L}{n}\) becomes equal to \(2d\), then \(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\) becomes \(0\), and the volume of browned apple will be exactly the same as the total volume of apple! So everything will be brown! That's somewhat what we achieved, but our apples were not perfect cubes, and we were not cutting like that, but we still got the pieces so small that the depth \(d\) of the browning became enough to turn everything brown!

Dividing the total volume of browned apple \(n^3\left[\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3\right]\) by the total volume of apple \(L^3\) gives the fraction of the apple that turns brown: \[\begin{aligned} \frac{n^3\left[\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3\right]}{L^3} &= \frac{n^3 L^3}{n^3 L^3} - \frac{n^3}{L^3}\left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3 \\ &= 1 - \left(\frac{n}{L}\right)^3\left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3 \\ &= 1 - \left[\frac{n}{L}\left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)\right]^3 \\ &= 1 - \left(\frac{L}{n}\cdot\frac{n}{L} - 2d\cdot\frac{n}{L}\right)^3 \\ &= 1 - \left(1 - \frac{2dn}{L}\right)^3. \end{aligned}\] This only works until \(\frac{L}{n} = 2d\); after that, it is all brown. For an apple of \(L = 8\) cm and a browning depth of \(d = 2\) mm (my guess, not a measurement), the whole peeled apple is about \(14\%\) brown, halves are \(27\%\), \(5\) segments per side are \(58\%\), \(10\) are \(87.5\%\), and at \(20\) segments per side everything is brown.

Slice through the middle of the apple
15101520 0%25%50%75%100% Segments per side, n Browned apple (%)

1 piece, 8 cm wide, 14.26% brown


^ [1] The idea behind \(L^3 - (L - 2d)^3\) is to take the whole volume of the apple and subtract the inside that is still fresh. That inside is a cube whose side is reduced by \(d\) at each end, leaving a side of \(L - 2d\).

This is not the same as multiplying the exposed surface by \(d\). If we did that, we would count each of the \(12\) edges twice (because each edge connects two faces) and each of the \(8\) vertices three times (because each vertex connects three faces). Expanding the formula shows the correction: \[L^3 - (L - 2d)^3 = 6L^2d - 12Ld^2 + 8d^3.\]

The \(6L^2d\) is the volume of the \(6\) faces, but it counts each edge twice, so we remove the \(12\) edges once: \(-12Ld^2\). The faces also counted each vertex three times, and removing the edges removed each vertex three times too (because each vertex connects three edges). That leaves the vertices not counted at all, so we add them back in: \(+8d^3\).

Reasonablesourcing

Entry Slip: October 1

This passage made me stop on three different points and made me question two other things.

Buying Less

The first stop was "We buy less, we check labels, shift lumber choices and do research on a country's environmental policies or a company's factory conditions". And I really like Kallis' following statement: "We use our purchasing power to dictate the terms of consumerism we want". That is my approach: buy less. And most of the time when I buy something, I try to see what I'm financing. But it's impossible to completely follow the money trail. You have to decide how far your responsibility as a consumer extends: is it just the materials used? Does it extend to checking the company culture/structure/impact? Do we look for parent companies, holdings, and subsidiaries? Do we (and even can we) go as deep as checking what the employees do with the money they receive from the company that you are financing?

Fossil Fuel

The second stop was on "This has only been possible since the advent of cheap fossil fuels", that Kallis mentions right after "From outsourcing to local factories, then national factories, and finally to developing nations, we have happily divested the responsibility of taking care of ourselves". And the question is, what is "this" (in "this has only been possible") referring to? If it is referring to overseas production, meaning the argument is that modern, inexpensive, highly globalized manufacturing depends heavily on fossil fuels, that's defensible. But if it is referring to divesting the responsibility of taking care of ourselves, then I have to disagree. Specialization and trade existed thousands of years before industrial fossil fuels. From smiths, to potters, to cobblers, to tailors, to fishers. Humans have been outsourcing taking care of ourselves for millennia. Definitely not at the same scale of modern outsourcing, I know.

Doomsday

The third stop was when Kallis warned that "doomsday lectures scare many people away". I agree with that. And change, to be effective, have to be doable. Any change in lifestyle, if too drastic, won't last long. Small changes can make more difference in the long run than an abrupt change that gets unchanged.

Reflection

Then this text brought me to think about two topics:

Does producing locally necessarily mean producing more sustainably?

This would require some better research, but maybe the efficiency of the industrialized, professional, mass production of some product may be less wasteful. So not only the sourcing of the production, but also the means of production, matter.

Is relying on others necessarily a bad thing?

An important part of the idea of backsourcing was building community. And I understand that having a connection with a manufacturer in a factory overseas is more complicated than with someone next to you going over the same activity. But maybe some small degree of outsourcing can be beneficial to community making.

Friday, October 16, 2026

Measurements

Exit Slip: September 24

For most daily uses of measurement, people just need a rough idea of the measurement, and being able to use something that is always close at hand, like for example, your hand, is, well… handy.

Body Parts

I think, for me at least, most of the time that I use my body parts to measure something is to look for proportions and scales: it doesn’t matter the length o my index finger, but measuring something to be roughly 5 index fingers and something else to be 2 and something index fingers, it’s safe to say one is double the other. Other than that it also really helps to have a known body measurement that translate nicely to a well defined standard unit of measurement, like having a hand span of almost exactly 20cm. But even if it’s not exactly 20cm, if it’s anything longer than 15cm and you know it’s approximate length you can at least measure to see if an IKEA desk is 65cm or 75cm deep. It all comes down to the accumulation and propagation of the error of your measurement versus the precision you are trying to achieve.

Another cool thing that was mentioned in class is being able to know where in your chest compared to a specific point in your hand is a meter, and being able to replicate that with some level of precision can help a lot!

For me, the problem is when we start trying to take those measurements too precisely. Some of the measurements that appeared on the table differ by about 10 to 15%. They are roughly the same thing. A non-fully stretched hand span is almost the same thing as a hand length. A foot and a forearm are usually the same length! But they are the same inaccurate measurement. And I’m okay with using body parts as the first step of design, but then creating ropes and sticks for better precision and accurate measurements.

Longer Distances

When we were tasked with measuring the garden, most of us started walking, and some tried to measure in feet. Feet would definitely be a more accurate measurement versus steps, as steps rely on an arbitrary opening of the legs. Steps are way faster, though. It was also fun to be counting my steps, pass by someone counting theirs, and immediately lose count of my steps.

I wanted to measure using math. And I had the idea of similar triangles. I cheated a bit because I used a ruler, but my idea was to walk some arbitrary distance away from the thing we needed to measure, hold a ruler a fixed distance from my eyes (an arm length), and measure it with the ruler from a distance, and then I’d just need to figure out the scaling factor. My initial idea was to know how many arm lengths away from the target I was and multiply. But then I’d have to measure a long distance with inaccurate measurements. I was not happy with it. But then it struck me: I just need to measure something from the same distance holding the ruler at the same distance from my eyes, and then get the measurement of that thing up close. I would just be scaling the distance, not exactly a triangle. It’s still somewhat triangular in the principle, I guess.

So my measurement was a classmate! I measured them to be 3cm from afar, and the whole distance I needed to measure was 90cm from afar, to it was 30 classmates. Then I just had to ask the classmate their height and multiply by 30 to get a fair approximation of the total distance I needed to measure.

That could be achieved even without the ruler! If I measured the total distance from afar to be 4 hand spans and measured the classmate to be two pinky finger widths from afar, and knowing that my hand span is 15 pinky widths, I could get that the total distance was 30 classmates long. Then I’d just have to know the height of the classmate in whatever measurements I wanted and multiply by 30.

Teaching and Learning Gardens

Entrance Slip: September 24

Garden as a Co-Teacher

The first stop for me was the first time the concept of garden as a co-teacher was mentioned. My first real question was: does the intent to teach matter to be considered a co-teacher? Wouldn’t the garden be more of a “subject expert” or “guest speaker(?)” of some sort? Then my mind derailed to some weirder questions. Would a garden need a certification to become a co-teacher? Does the UBC Orchard Garden have enough class hours and practice hours to get the certification? Would we then transfer the UBC Orchard Garden to another school? Would just saps of the trees in the UBC Orchard Garden be enough?

I was obviously not questioning the usage of the garden as a co-teacher, I was more questioning the word co-teacher and the fantastical requirements for a garden co-teacher.

The Indoor Outdoor

The second stop was when it was mentioned that some of the planners were asking questions that made it clear that their idea of an “outdoor classroom” was just an indoor classroom outdoors. The learning would not happen outdoors, the classroom itself would be outdoors. That’s just the same idea as a portable. Portables are outdoor indoor classrooms. But that was not the goal, the goal was for the learning to happen outdoors, and for that we just need the class, not the room. It is just interesting how people even with the best of intentions are still “locked” with the traditional idea of a classroom. 

The Central Work

This last stop was definitely the strongest (not the longest, as my first derailing stop took quite some time), as it made me solidify the main goal: the central work. The lesson from the Evergreen Foundation that the garden has to do the central work of the institution is what makes the garden really a part of it. If not, it is just a prop. And if it’s just a prop it’s easy to get rid of. If the garden is an integral part of the teaching then it is not as easily disposable. 

The Garden as My Future Co-Teacher

Teaching IN the garden is easy, you just go there and teach there. Done. Teaching WITH the garden is something more complex that requires intentional planning. I don’t have a perfectly clear idea of how to implement it, but I truly think virtually anything can be taught in a way that incorporates the garden, be it in the plants, in the nature, in the space, the atmosphere, the openness, the garden is a vast system rather than a single thing, so the possibilities are endless.

I think the most difficult thing is finding the right subject and the right approach in a way that the teaching can be done, that the subject can be taught, that the learning can happen, and that the students are engaged. And honestly, lesson planning is already difficult even without the garden, adding the garden requires a strong change in the mindset. It may become easier with practice. Practice that I, for now, lack.

Some ideas of subjects that I think can teach with the garden are Geometry (symmetry, transformation, spatial reasoning), Fractions (ratios, proportions, scales, growth), and even add some Statistics and Probability.

Sitting Spot and Drawing

Exit Slip: September 17

The drawing/sketching activity had us select a sitting spot and drawing two things from nature and two things human-made, with focus on lines and angles.

The Sitting Spot

My first issue was finding a sitting spot. A place in nature where you can come back to repeatedly, be mindful and connect to nature. How am I supposed to do that out of nowhere? Decide something like that in one go? In just five minutes! Feels like choosing my favourite ice cream before ever tasting any ice cream at all. A spot where I can connect to nature and be mindful…

Mindful… My second issue is with all that on-demand mindfulness. I could argue that forced mindfulness is no mindfulness at all. I think “mindfulness” is thrown around as that LinkedIn buzzword that is supposed to make everything better. The MSG of the mind. Just add some industrialized, forced, insincere mindfulness and somehow everything is better.

Then there is the connection with nature. My third issue. I may be just bad at connecting with nature, but I don’t think the orchard garden cuts it for me. It may be the best thing we have on campus, and it’s definitely better than just a potted plant (although someone really good at connecting with nature could possibly do it with a potted plant), but the orchard garden feels too artificial for me. It is planned, it is designed, it is a human-made nature block surrounded by the concrete city. It may be because I’m from Rio, where the city is mostly a narrow corridor of concrete with beaches on one side and the Atlantic forest on the other. You may be in the busiest business center in Copacabana and you are still no more than two blocks away from untamed, unmanaged wilderness. When nature is so in your face like that you don’t really need a lot of effort to connect with it. Maybe I didn’t develop that skill enough to be able to really connect with nature in the orchard garden. Or maybe I am good, and I am able to connect, but the reception is not great and it just doesn’t surprise me. I don’t know. I still think it’s easier (or stronger) to connect with nature hiking the Garibaldi, Golden Ears, or Manning Park than it is to connect sitting on the bench at the orchard garden.

The Drawing

When I finally chose my sitting spot to be the exact same place I was sitting to begin with, I had planned to draw the orchard shed. When I knew what the activity was, and the focus on lines and angles, I knew it would be human-made structures follow straight lines, sharp angles, hard edges, while the natural structures would be more fluid, curved, irregular.

So I was getting ready to draw the shed when I noticed a classmate squatting down in front of the garden sign (most likely drawing it). I looked at them and that was it. Nothing could represent better the human-nature contrast than, well, a human. I’m not good at drawing at all, but I tried, and I believe with the right skill it could have been a really interesting drawing. Drawing my classmate squatting you could see the form was human, was natural, no hard edges or sharp angles. But then they were wearing glasses, hard edges and sharp angles, in contrast with their face (that I did a terrible job at drawing). And they were wearing I believe it was Adidas pants, with the three stripes from the waist to the ankle. Those are, technically, three parallel lines, but as my classmate was squatting, the form of the leg distorted the once straight lines into a more natural and organic line. They were also wearing a hoodie with painted coloured leaves, and what was interesting is that they were supposed to mimic something natural and they were the same colours as the garden sign, that was also trying to mimic something natural!

I ended up drawing the classmate, the garden sign, and the tree behind it. I had two natural things: the tree and the classmate; and two human-made things: the garden sign and the classmate.

I think the garden sign was nice because it was trying to be “naturey”, but was still some well cut rectangular wooden planks, attached to vertical wooden sticks with a wooden bar for stability in the middle. It was interesting that none of that was as perfect as I envisioned: it was a bit crooked, things were not absolutely straight, not the exact same size. But those were imperfections while trying to make perfection (in structure), with some imperfections (nature/plants) painted on it.

The tree was interesting because it doesn’t make a lot of sense, it’s like the tree just goes “yeah, I think I’ll sprout a branch here”, and then it does. It doesn’t look like it follows function or form, but I’m sure it does. The tree functions, the tree doesn’t crumble down to pieces. Everything is so in-place and perfect exactly because it’s all over the place and imperfect. Every single iteration of growth from the tree is perfect and calculated in the given instant it happens, but the growth process takes so much time and the environment is so dynamic that when you look at it it seems like chaos.

I’ll end by saying that for my natural thing, instead of the tree I wanted some vines or climbing plants on a human-made structure. I think it would be nice to have the sign “mimicking” nature with the paintings on it, but also the vine “mimicking” the human-made structure, even if only by following its form. I just spent  too much time drawing my classmate that I didn’t have time to look for the perfect match for my composition.

Monday, October 12, 2026

Teacher Man

Entrance/Exit slip: September 10

I’ll start by saying that the overall idea behind the whole interview is a positive one, and one interesting approach that McCourt adopted was weaving between the two competing schools of thought of “don’t tell too much about yourself when teaching” and “be open with the kids”. The idea of dropping the act is not about sharing absolutely everything about your personal life, it is just not having a persona. It's about not wearing a mask, even if you have to set some boundaries. The constant effort of not being yourself every day must be draining, and there is a chance your personality will slip and show up, and that’s why McCourt mentions that you will most likely eventually drop the act.

Even if I agree and understand most of what was said, there were two things that I noticed that could have been put in a more sensible way.

The first was when McCourt mentioned his difficult past and his successful escape from those difficulties. I understand his early life may have been hard, and I am glad he was able to overcome it and rise to a better life. What I think could have been better would be the recognition of the things that played a role in his survival of his miserable childhood. The way he attributes his success to his dreaming about getting out of it could imply that the ones that don’t succeed just didn’t dream hard enough. Dreaming of escaping a difficult situation may be crucial to not giving up, but just not giving up is not enough to succeed. Many things can influence the overcoming of a situation, and more often than not, luck is part of it. Attributing the whole success to a thing as simple as just dreaming, something that anyone could do, can come across as a bit shallow and disregard important factors that are not accessible to everyone.

The other moment was when he mentioned how the GI Bill helped him get admission and embark on the teaching career. Even though the GI Bill was a benefit for him, the circumstances that made the bill possible and the global context around the situation that brought him this opportunity are less lucky than he made it seem. He mentions that "luckily enough" there was a war, he was drafted into the U.S. Army, and he could benefit from the GI Bill. I understand that being somewhat favourable for him, but I would not say any kind of human conflict where lives are lost is a lucky situation.

I get that the main goal of the video was not about those two slips, but sometimes the intended message is not exactly what draws most of the attention.