Monday, October 19, 2026

Reasonablesourcing

Entry Slip: October 1

This passage made me stop on three different points and made me question two other things.

Buying Less

The first stop was "We buy less, we check labels, shift lumber choices and do research on a country's environmental policies or a company's factory conditions". And I really like Kallis' following statement: "We use our purchasing power to dictate the terms of consumerism we want". That is my approach: buy less. And most of the time when I buy something, I try to see what I'm financing. But it's impossible to completely follow the money trail. You have to decide how far your responsibility as a consumer extends: is it just the materials used? Does it extend to checking the company culture/structure/impact? Do we look for parent companies, holdings, and subsidiaries? Do we (and even can we) go as deep as checking what the employees do with the money they receive from the company that you are financing?

Fossil Fuel

The second stop was on "This has only been possible since the advent of cheap fossil fuels", that Kallis mentions right after "From outsourcing to local factories, then national factories, and finally to developing nations, we have happily divested the responsibility of taking care of ourselves". And the question is, what is "this" (in "this has only been possible") referring to? If it is referring to overseas production, meaning the argument is that modern, inexpensive, highly globalized manufacturing depends heavily on fossil fuels, that's defensible. But if it is referring to divesting the responsibility of taking care of ourselves, then I have to disagree. Specialization and trade existed thousands of years before industrial fossil fuels. From smiths, to potters, to cobblers, to tailors, to fishers. Humans have been outsourcing taking care of ourselves for millennia. Definitely not at the same scale of modern outsourcing, I know.

Doomsday

The third stop was when Kallis warned that "doomsday lectures scare many people away". I agree with that. And change, to be effective, have to be doable. Any change in lifestyle, if too drastic, won't last long. Small changes can make more difference in the long run than an abrupt change that gets unchanged.

Reflection

Then this text brought me to think about two topics:

Does producing locally necessarily mean producing more sustainably?

This would require some better research, but maybe the efficiency of the industrialized, professional, mass production of some product may be less wasteful. So not only the sourcing of the production, but also the means of production, matter.

Is relying on others necessarily a bad thing?

An important part of the idea of backsourcing was building community. And I understand that having a connection with a manufacturer in a factory overseas is more complicated than with someone next to you going over the same activity. But maybe some small degree of outsourcing can be beneficial to community making.

No comments:

Post a Comment