Monday, October 19, 2026

Apple Cider

Exit Slip: October 1

I’ll start by admitting that making apple cider was definitely not on my UBC Bachelor of Education bingo card…

It was really good, though!

Even with the spider!

The Process

There were many tasks: setting up the working tables, assembling the press, putting up the canopies to protect from the rain, washing parts, and, no less important, understanding how the water valve works. Many students played different roles in the process, but we had only one that really understood the water valve, so whenever we needed water, we had to call the one known as The Water Bender.

I did mostly washing at the beginning and then pulling the manual food processor string. Handling the manual food processor was a dangerous task, as the blades are insanely sharp and you have to constantly open it and remove the blades to remove the minced apple. It was arduous and dangerous, but we managed to end the day with but a single small injury. I call it a success!

One interesting thing was the oxidation of the apple. When I think of apple juice, I don't think of a brown juice. I understand the oxidation process, but it's a different scale. Everything was brown! 

After a whole pitcher of apple juice, some students brought berries to add to the press to make an apple-berry juice! It was nice to mix things up a bit, and after pressing the juice, we found a spider inside the press. No one is completely sure how it didn't squish the spider, but it was alive afterwards, so we didn't drink spider juice. Worst case, if it was scared, we may have had some spider sweat! (I'm pretty sure they don't do that, though.)

The Math

I think the most basic math for this activity would be just the proportion of apples to juice.

There is also the basic idea of a function. The press is a juice maker: you input apple, it outputs apple juice; you input berry, it makes berry juice. Basically, juice of \(x\)!

Then there is a deeper math to be explored with the browning of the apple. The browning is oxidation that happens on the surface of the apple, while the insides of the apple remain fresh. That is the idea I want to explore a bit more.

The Browning of the Apple

There are two simple approaches that I thought of that show that the more you cut the apple, the browner everything gets:

  • If we think that if we cut the apple in half, each half of the apple will have exactly half of the volume of the original apple, and each half will have exactly half of the surface of the apple plus the amount of new surface you created with the cut. Basically, with every cut you are never adding more apple flesh but are always adding more exposed surface.
  • A bit more complex, but still simple to understand, is the idea that the volume is a cubic measurement and that the surface is a square measurement. Whatever the shape, a cube or a sphere, the surface divided by the volume is proportional to \(\frac{L^2}{L^3} = \frac{1}{L}\), so it is inversely proportional to the size of the piece. Halving the size doubles the exposed surface per unit of apple.

Sadly for this example, I may have to borrow from the classic physics metaphorical joke of a perfectly spherical and homogenous apple in the vacuum with no friction. Okay, possibly not in the vacuum, because it needs to be exposed to oxygen to oxidize... And maybe a cubic apple would be easier to calculate, honestly.

But imagining that the apple is a cube, that the browning of the apple happens only on the flesh of the apple, not on the juice after it is pressed, and that the browning happens for only a specific depth, then we can model the browning of the apple!

If we assume a peeled cubic apple of side \(L\), with browning depth of \(d\), the volume of the apple is \(L^3\), the exposed surface of the apple is \(6L^2\), and the volume of browned apple would be \(L^3 - (L - 2d)^3\)[1]. If we cut the length \(L\) in half we would have \(8\) pieces of volume \(\left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^3\), and the total volume of browned apple would be \(8\left[\left(\frac{L}{2}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{2} - 2d\right)^3\right]\). If we cut the length \(L\) in \(n\) segments we would have \(n^3\) pieces of volume \(\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3\), and the total volume of browned apple would be \(n^3\left[\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3\right]\). We can see by that formula for the browned apple that when \(\frac{L}{n}\) becomes equal to \(2d\), then \(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\) becomes \(0\), and the volume of browned apple will be exactly the same as the total volume of apple! So everything will be brown! That's somewhat what we achieved, but our apples were not perfect cubes, and we were not cutting like that, but we still got the pieces so small that the depth \(d\) of the browning became enough to turn everything brown!

Dividing the total volume of browned apple \(n^3\left[\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3\right]\) by the total volume of apple \(L^3\) gives the fraction of the apple that turns brown: \[\begin{aligned} \frac{n^3\left[\left(\frac{L}{n}\right)^3 - \left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3\right]}{L^3} &= \frac{n^3 L^3}{n^3 L^3} - \frac{n^3}{L^3}\left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3 \\ &= 1 - \left(\frac{n}{L}\right)^3\left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)^3 \\ &= 1 - \left[\frac{n}{L}\left(\frac{L}{n} - 2d\right)\right]^3 \\ &= 1 - \left(\frac{L}{n}\cdot\frac{n}{L} - 2d\cdot\frac{n}{L}\right)^3 \\ &= 1 - \left(1 - \frac{2dn}{L}\right)^3. \end{aligned}\] This only works until \(\frac{L}{n} = 2d\); after that, it is all brown. For an apple of \(L = 8\) cm and a browning depth of \(d = 2\) mm (my guess, not a measurement), the whole peeled apple is about \(14\%\) brown, halves are \(27\%\), \(5\) segments per side are \(58\%\), \(10\) are \(87.5\%\), and at \(20\) segments per side everything is brown.

Slice through the middle of the apple
15101520 0%25%50%75%100% Segments per side, n Browned apple (%)

1 piece, 8 cm wide, 14.26% brown


^ [1] The idea behind \(L^3 - (L - 2d)^3\) is to take the whole volume of the apple and subtract the inside that is still fresh. That inside is a cube whose side is reduced by \(d\) at each end, leaving a side of \(L - 2d\).

This is not the same as multiplying the exposed surface by \(d\). If we did that, we would count each of the \(12\) edges twice (because each edge connects two faces) and each of the \(8\) vertices three times (because each vertex connects three faces). Expanding the formula shows the correction: \[L^3 - (L - 2d)^3 = 6L^2d - 12Ld^2 + 8d^3.\]

The \(6L^2d\) is the volume of the \(6\) faces, but it counts each edge twice, so we remove the \(12\) edges once: \(-12Ld^2\). The faces also counted each vertex three times, and removing the edges removed each vertex three times too (because each vertex connects three edges). That leaves the vertices not counted at all, so we add them back in: \(+8d^3\).

No comments:

Post a Comment