Monday, October 26, 2026

Ropes and Poems

Exit Slip: October 8

Ropes

This exercise was really interesting. One problem that I had with the activity was that at the end we were expected to show our ropes. And I had none. What I was doing was trying different fibre type compositions (grass and/or corn husk) and the number of strands. I was twisting the strands to make a rope, and when I had a long enough rope, I would pull it until it snapped. I was just testing the maximum load of the rope. And then I would try with one more strand, or with the other type of fibre, or mix the fibres, and test the maximum load again. So at the end I had no rope to show. I had just many snapped and destroyed segments of rope. Which is not exactly great. But I had a lot of data points.

I think a lot of the process can be connected to math. For example, in a way, the sequential nature of rope twisting is pretty similar to the sequential nature of mathematical algorithms. Where one step done wrong can compromise the entire resulting rope/solution.

But more than that, I think there is a real physical and mathematical experiment that can be done with the strands and the rope. Twisting the rope reduces the length of the strand while increasing the thickness, and, as expected, increasing the maximum load of the rope. And then we could start using math and experiments to make calculations:

  • Measuring the maximum load of isolated strands and many strands, does the maximum load increase linearly?
  • Do both fibres have the same maximum load per amount of fibre? Or are they different?
  • Assuming the volume of the rope stays the same, how could we calculate the increase in thickness given a measured decrease in length of the strands?
  • How much of the rope’s maximum load depends on the thickness (or the area of the cross-section) of the rope?

This all feels more “Physics Lab” than “Math Class”, but I think they are not too far apart. This may be my Mechanical Engineering background surfacing in my teaching ideas. Still doable, I think, and still instructional.

Poems

The poem activity was a bit harder for me. I don’t consider myself a highly on-demand-creative person, so writing a poem in a few minutes is harder for me. I appreciate doing that as a group exercise, because I honestly didn’t do much. But I was, in my head, constantly thinking about something individual. And I didn’t get to a nice poem. But I got to some ideas that I later iterated on.

Keeping in mind the 27 digits: 2.71828182845904523536028747.

My original idea was to have a nice word-by-word poem, where each digit would be a word, and I thought about having the text be minimally mathematical, and maybe, if possible, having the “words” be mathematical symbols.

The ending 8747 I immediately thought of having it as “for ever and ever”, that would already lock 8 = “for”, 7 = “ever”, and 4 = “and”. And I thought that, for representing that as mathematical symbols we could have “for” as being a “4”, “ever” could be “∞” maybe, and “and” could be the logical “∧”. It wasn’t good, honestly, but the idea was not absolutely discarded.

Just with the 8 fixed as “for”, that would make the 18281828 to be “1 for 2 for 1 for 2 for”. That segment is also limited by a 7 on the left and a 4 on the right, making the segment be “ever 1 for 2 for 1 for 2 for and”.

The “for and” was not great, but I thought that maybe “for and” could be “for and by” something. That would lock 5 as by, and the 9 would be something, and that’s good, because the 9 there is the only occurrence of 9, so we are completely free of what to put in there.

So far we have “2 ever 1 for 2 for 1 for 2 for and by 9 0 and by 2 3 by 3 6 0 2 for ever and ever”.

The “for 1 for 2” I thought could be “for you for me”, and I iterated that, it wasn’t terrible, but that would make the start 271 to be “me ever you”, or “you ever me”, depending on which one of 1 and 2 would be “me” and which one would be “you”. It was bad. And that’s where my in-class thought process ended. I wasn’t happy about that. But I had to do something, and so I joined a group and focused on the group work. And we did okay. It was a good experience working with the group, and they were really creative. I was not able to finish a poem entirely by myself with the given time. A couple students did solo poems and group poems, but I'm not that fast with on-demand creativity.

But I didn’t stop thinking about it, and I iterated on it, and I tried to make it work. I ended up giving up the idea of mathematical symbols and also gave up on the idea of making the poem mathematical. I could not justify trying to make it mathematical, and the symbols for “ever”, “for”, and “and” were not great, but adding the “by” made it even worse. So it was just a poem now.

I still had “me” and “you” as base ideas for 1 and 2, but it wasn’t great, but we can try using “someone” and “another” as placeholders: “someone ever another, for someone, for another, for someone, for and by 9 0 and by someone 3 by 3 6 0 someone for ever and ever”.

With the idea of “me” and “you” or “someone” and “another”, the “for and by 9”, we could have 9 as “us” or “everyone”. That wouldn’t be terrible. Then we have the “6 0” close before the “for ever and ever”, and before that the “3 by 3”. Looking at the “3 by 3”, I could only think of “4 by 4”, but that’s not it! I could think of “little by little”.

The poem was starting to get form, but my efforts were starting to reach my literary limit. I spent most of my efforts thinking about the 1 and 2, which I was not happy about. Then I had the idea of making it educational, using “teachers” and “students”. That could work! We would have:

Teachers, ever students,
For teachers, for students, for teachers,
For and by us 0
And by teachers, little by little
6 0
Teachers, for ever and ever.

That was my limit. I then resorted to brainstorming with AI, and it gave me good directions. For the 6, Claude suggested “until”, and for the 0 “now”. So we would have:

…
For and by us now
…
Until now
…

That was a start, but not great. I then changed the line of “until now” to “from now”, but it was still not good, though I thought it had a good synergy with “for ever and ever”. But it would be best if it was “from now on”, but then “for and by us now on” was not good. Then I thought about “today” instead of “now”, so we would have

…
For and by us today
…
From today
Teachers, for ever and ever.

Not bad at all! But the “for and by us” was not great. Maybe “for and by everyone”. Or maybe, as Claude suggested, “for and by the people”, but then having 9 as "the people", it would be the only digit to have two words in it, so I stuck with "everyone". Claude also suggested "step by step" for the 353, and I liked it.

I don’t know, I’m not great with poems in my first language. And in English it’s even worse. But my final composition was:

Given the base 2.71828182845904523536028747

And ordering it as

271
828182
84590
452353
60
28747

And having:

  1. today
  2. students
  3. teachers
  4. step
  5. and
  6. by
  7. from
  8. ever
  9. for
  10. everyone

With that, the final product was:

Teachers, ever students,
For teachers, for students, for teachers,
For and by everyone today,
And by teachers, step by step,
From today,
Teachers, for ever and ever.

And that was good enough for me. Could possibly be improved, but not by me.

1 comment:

  1. Wow, Francisco!! You are definitely of a poetic frame of mind. Only a poet would have such concentration and, well, something verging on an obsession to make the patterns work well. That is really how artists in every medium work. And I love the E poem you’ve created here! Bravo!! (Just trying to think how I would try to take such a thing on in Portuguese too … it’s an exponentially more difficult process in an additional language.) Your rope experiments are fascinating as well, and very scientific in their approach. Those destroyed bits of rope were evidence of experimentation at work!

    ReplyDelete